Friday, November 18, 2011

You Hear Me?: Poems and Writing by Teenage Boys by Betty Franco

Summary:
You Hear Me? is a collection of poems and short essays written by teenage boys.  The topics vary from relationships and sex to drugs and emotions.  These young men come from different backgrounds and it is displayed in their words which are powerful and real.

Reaction:
I was surprised by the strong emotions presented by these young men.  Boys are known for not expressing their feelings verbally.  These boys not only proved that the can express themselves, but that they can express themselves with amazing depth and creativity.

Friday, November 11, 2011

Tales From Outer Suburbia by Shaun Tan


Summary:

A collection of stories that are funny, touching, and sometimes strange which all happen is the world of suburbia.  Each story is illustrated with pictures that are just as funny and strange as the stories with something out of place that is sure to catch your eye.



Reaction:
I enjoyed this collection of stories which seem to center around the theme of misunderstanding.  Nothing was as it appeared and this seemed to cause some confusion in each of the stories.
Tan, S. (2008). Tales from outer suburbia. New York: Arthur A. Levine Books.

TWILIGHT GRAPHIC NOVELS - Vol. 1 and Vol. 2 by Stephanie Meyers












Summary:
Bella is a teenager who decides to move to Forks, WA to live with her dad after her mom remarries.  She expects to be miserable in the gloomy small town and at first that is exactly how she feels.  The weather is horrible most of the time, there isn’t much to do, and there is a gorgeous and very mysterious guy who seems to dislike her for no apparent reason.  Things do begin to brighten as she makes some new friends, but her world really begins to change when she realizes that she and the mysterious guy, Edward, have a very strong connection.  Bella searches for the reason for Edward and his family’s strange behavior, only to discover that they are vampires.  But it is too late; Bella has already begun to fall for Edward and wants to be with him constantly.  Edward wants only to protect Bella, even if that means having to stay away from her forever.
Reaction:
I am not a fan of the Twilight series.  I found the characters to be whinny and annoying.  These graphic novels changed all that.  Yes the characters were still whinny, but the art work grabbed my interest and took the focus off their annoying behavior.  The facial expressions in the pictures also made the story seem more real and interesting.  I think I will have to take another look at graphic novels.
Meyers, S. (2010). Twilight: The graphic novel-Vol. 1.New York: Yen Press.
Meyers, S. (2011). Twilight: The graphic novel-Vol. 2.New York: Yen Press.

American Born Chinese by Gene Luen Yang

Summary:
American Born Chinese tells three separate stories that combine to give different views of the Chinese culture.  The first story is about the Monkey King, from Chinese fables, who wants to be more than the king of the monkeys.  He manages to rise to the status of a god but ultimately learns there is more than just power.  The second story is about a fifth grader, Jin Wang, who has to deal with being a minority in his school.  He is picked on and stereotyped by his peers but eventually another Asian student arrives and after a not so friendly meeting they soon become friends.  The third and final story is about Jin Wang’s cousin, Chin-Kee, who has just recently arrived in America.  As he tries to adjust to his new life he causes some problems for his cousin.
Reaction:
I really liked this book and I am not typically a fan of graphic novels.  I liked how the three stories were not completely separate, but they were intertwined throughout the book.  The main theme appeared to be accepting yourself for who you are and not losing yourself or your culture just to fit in, a great lesson for anyone to learn.

Yang, G. L. (2006). American born Chinese. New York: First Second.

Friday, November 4, 2011

Monster by Walter Dean Myers

Summary:
Steve Harmon is only sixteen years old but he is already on trial for felony murder.  Steve is not suspected of committing the murder, he is suspected of participating in a robbery which led to the death of a drugstore owner.  There is no clear proof that Harmon had anything to do with the robbery, only what acquaintances who have also been accused of felony murder and a store customer are saying about him.  During his trail, Harmon deals with the possibility of going to prison for a very long time.  He does so by writing in a journal and describing the trail in the form of a screen play.  Steve Harmon must decide if he is the Monster that the prosecutor has called him.

Reaction:
Although the delivery of the story was unique, I did not like the back and forth from the narrative story to the screen play.  I felt the screen play only interrupted the story and didn’t allow it to flow at a steady pace.  I was also disappointed with the ending which still left me wondering if Harmon was innocent or guilty, even after the verdict.

Myers, W. D. (1999). Monster. New York: HarperTempest.

Stuck in Neutral by Terry Trueman


Summary:
Shawn McDaniel is fourteen-years-old and he has cerebral palsy.  He has no control over his body but his mind is alert and fully aware.  He can even remember everything he ever hears.  Unfortunately, no one knows that Shawn understands everything that is happening around him, not even his dad, who Shawn suspects is trying to kill him.  Shawn doesn’t want to die, but he is unable to let his dad know.  He knows his dad loves him and only wants to end his suffering.  Shawn is not sure if his dad with go through with it, but he knows that he will always love him.

Reaction:
The idea that someone like Shawn could be aware that someone else wants to kill them and they are unable to do anything about it is chilling.  This reminds us that medical technology has come far but still has a long way to go.  I empathized with the suffering the family.  As a mother, I understand the need to want to protect your child from pain and suffering, desire to give them a future full of possibilities.

Trueman, T. (2008). Stuck in neutral. New York: HarperCollins Publishers.

Mockingbird by Kathryn Erskine


Summary:
Caitlin is a fifth grade student with Asperger’s.  Her brother is killed in a school shooting and Caitlin is having a hard time dealing with his death and the emotions of everyone around her.  She just doesn’t Get It.  Caitlin doesn’t like people asking her how she’s feeling, nor all the crying her dad is doing.  But she does like words and she has found a new one, Closure.  She looks it up in her dictionary and realizes that closure is what everyone needs.  Now if only she can find it. 


Reaction:
Death is hard for anyone to deal with, especially a child, but I can only imagine how difficult it would be for a person who has trouble understanding emotions.  I liked the idea of Caitlin learning to empathize with others and finding closure for the community.  My only complaint with this story is that it seemed rushed.  If it had been longer then maybe the characters could have had more depth and Caitlin’s journey may have been more realistic.

Erskine, K. (2010). Mockingbird. New York: Philomel Books.

The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian by Sherman Alexie


Summary:

Arnold Spirit, Junior, is an Indian who lives on a reservation in Spokane, Washington.  He was born with excess spinal fluid in his skull which caused him to have physical problems.  The other children on the reservation bully him and beat him up.  Junior must also deal the extreme poverty of his family and everyone else on the reservation. 

After discovering that his textbook is the same one his mother used thirty years earlier and talking to his teacher, Junior decides to attend the white high school near the reservation.  His transfer starts off rocky (he loses his best friend and protector), but he eventually makes friends and begins to fit in.  As the year progresses, Junior’s life is once again filled with pain caused by family tragedy.  In the end, he makes up with his best friend and realizes that he has a chance for a bright future.

Reaction:

This book brought to life the extreme poverty on an Indian reservation.  The story shows that such poverty can bring with it the loss of hope and escape through alcohol.  Junior’s courage and strength was encouraging and up lifting.  He wasn’t the strongest kid at school, but he dared to dream of a better future.  Even with all the obstacles and tragedies in his life, Junior did not give up.  This story could bring hope to anyone.

Alexie, S. (2007). The absolutely true diary of a part-time Indian. Detroit, MI: Throndike Press.